Help us fight back against the rising tide of anti-Judaism and antisemitism in mainline Protestant churches

Subscribe to this blog for analysis and insight that the mainstream media refuses to notice.

Subscribe Theologic cover image
Beyond Interfaith as Usual
By Andrew Love profile image Andrew Love
4 min read

Beyond Interfaith as Usual

One painful fact that has emerged since the shock and theological ripple effect of the October 7, 2023 pogrom is that we can never return to the paradigm of interfaith dialogue that became commonplace in the post-Shoah era. We need to envision a completely different approach.

Alas, rather than confronting the explosion of Christian antisemitism that has been unleashed from mainline Protestant denominations, many interfaith institutions seem more interested in returning to the familiar model of shared lunches, workshops, public statements, and community events—a model that failed so miserably when it was most needed.

While there are many examples of this failure that will be the focus of broader research, the most illuminating starting point is Dabru Emet.

Dabru Emet and Its Eight Core Principles

Published on September 10, 2000, as a full-page advertisement in The New York Times and other major publications, Dabru Emet (Hebrew for "Speak the Truth," derived from Zechariah 8:16) was a landmark statement on Jewish-Christian relations. Developed under the auspices of the Institute for Christian and Jewish Studies (ICJS) by four prominent scholars—Tikva Frymer-Kensky, David Novak, Peter Ochs, and Michael Signer—the document was endorsed by over 220 rabbis and intellectuals across Reform, Conservative, Reconstructionist, and Orthodox streams of Judaism acting as individuals.

Formulated as a thoughtful Jewish response to post-Holocaust shifts in Christian theology—most notably the Second Vatican Council's Nostra Aetate, which repudiated historical anti-Judaism and affirmed God's enduring covenant with Israel—Dabru Emet set forth eight foundational principles to guide Jewish-Christian engagement:

  1. Jews and Christians worship the same God.
  2. Jews and Christians seek authority from the same book.
  3. Christians can respect the claim of the Jewish people upon the land of Israel.
  4. Jews and Christians together accept the moral principles of the Torah (Pentateuch).
  5. Nazism was not a Christian phenomenon.
  6. The controversy between Jews and Christians will not be settled until God redeems the entire world as promised in scripture, and no one should be pressed into believing another's belief.
  7. A new relationship between Jews and Christians will not weaken Jewish practice.
  8. Jews and Christians must work together for justice and peace.

To evaluate whether the post-Shoah interfaith framework remains viable today, we must examine how these principles function in the current landscape. While the first two principles remain widely endorsed across the mainline Christian world, the third principle has been effectively repudiated: mainline churches no longer respect the claim of the Jewish people upon the land of Israel.

The Repudiation of Principle 3: Three Rhetorical Axes

Examining the public declarations issued by mainline Christian denominations and ecumenical bodies since October 7, 2023, reveals a systematic erosion of the mutual respect envisioned by Dabru Emet. This repudiation manifests across three distinct rhetorical axes.

Axis 1: The Rhetoric of Genocide

Is it a sign of respect to routinely label Israel a "genocidal state"? While churches may legitimately raise ethical concerns regarding how Israel prosecutes military actions in Gaza, weaponizing the charge of genocide against the Jewish state represents a radical departure from constructive dialogue.

The accusation of genocide has become an established component of the public vocabulary of several major mainline Protestant denominations and ecumenical organizations. National assemblies that have formally adopted this terminology include:

Furthermore, joint statements issued by the leadership of Canadian Anglican, Lutheran, Presbyterian, and United Church denominations demonstrate explicit, coordinated accusations from senior officials across multiple bodies. Notably, there is no evidence that any of these denominations sought to rigorously examine or understand the strict legal parameters of genocide under international law before adopting the term. Instead, it has been deployed as an escalated rhetorical instrument against Israel.

Axis 2: The Accusation of Apartheid

Even if one were to argue that a denomination could express grave concerns over wartime conduct while still respecting Israel's core existence as a Jewish homeland, the widespread adoption of the "apartheid" label defies credulity.

In June 2025, the Central Committee of the World Council of Churches (WCC), meeting in Johannesburg, South Africa, issued a formal statement declaring:

"We recognize and denounce the system of apartheid imposed by Israel on the Palestinian people, in violation of international law and moral conscience."

This declaration followed official endorsements of the Apartheid Free Communities movement by major denominations and groups, including the United Church of Canada, the United Church of Christ, United Methodists for Kairos, and the Disciples of Christ. Calling the sole Jewish state an apartheid entity directly undermines its legitimacy, representing an explicit rejection of respect for the Jewish connection to the land.

Axis 3: The "Settler-Colonial" Framework and "Post-Gaza Theology"

The most disturbing post-October 7 development is the creeping adoption of "settler-colonial" terminology to describe Israel's very origin and presence. At the time Dabru Emet was drafted in 2000, labeling Israel a settler-colonial enterprise would have been anathema within mainstream interfaith circles. Today, however, that language is increasingly infiltrating official denomination reports and working group papers.

This shift frequently originates within specialized working groups, task forces, and subcommittees heavily influenced by anti-Israel activist networks like Kairos Palestine, who understand how to navigate and manipulate church polity. While full denominational approval often involves multi-year governance cycles—such as the three-year national assembly cycle of the United Church of Canada—the framework is already being weaponized under the banner of an emerging "post-Gaza theology."

The scale of this shift is already widespread:

  • In September 2025, the World Communion of Reformed Churches explicitly acknowledged in its 27th General Council Workbook (page 33) that member churches are deeply divided over whether to apply settler-colonial concepts to Israel.
  • Across mainline bodies, at least 20 public statements from 15 distinct denominations have utilized settler-colonial language to describe the State of Israel as a whole (distinct from specific critiques of West Bank settlements).

Moving Beyond the Broken Model

When mainline Christian bodies characterize Israel as a genocidal, apartheid, and settler-colonial entity, they are not merely expressing political disagreement over specific policies. They are participating in a coordinated campaign that delegitimizes the modern State of Israel at its foundation—thereby directly repudiating Dabru Emet's core assertion that "Christians can respect the claim of the Jewish people upon the land of Israel."

If interfaith dialogue is to have any integrity in the post-October 7 world, it cannot consist of returning to polite workshops and ceremonial statements while fundamental commitments to Jewish safety and national self-determination are dismantled. The failure of the post-Shoah interfaith model demands that we stop pretending the old baseline still holds, and instead begin building a new, honest framework for Jewish-Christian engagement.

By Andrew Love profile image Andrew Love
Updated on
interfaith Dabru Emet